Eminent Americans
Eminent Americans
On Privilege
0:00
Current time: 0:00 / Total time: -1:30:38
-1:30:38

On Privilege

Shamus Rahman Kahn and I discuss his great book *Privilege,* the subtleties of the American elite, and more.

My guest on this episode of the podcast is Princeton sociologist Shamus Rahman Kahn, who is the author of a number of books, most notably for our purposes Privilege: The Making of an Adolescent Elite at St. Paul’s School.

I described the book, in a previous post, thusly:

Privilege is an extraordinary book. People throw that word around too easily, but I really mean it in this case. It blew my mind in a way that it hadn’t been blown in a long while. Khan is a very good writer of sentences, an insightful theorist, and perhaps above all an observer of rare acuity. He just sees a lot more, and a lot more clearly, than most people would in a similar context, even if they went in with similarly ethnographic objectives. The result is a book packed with striking insight and fascinating detail. As it happens I went to a high school that wasn’t too different from St. Paul’s. It wasn’t as fancy, didn’t cater to quite as many sons and daughters of the high elite, but it was similar enough for me to vouch for Khan’s descriptions. They ring true. He captures with nuance what such places, which are so easy to caricature, are actually like.

The post that I wrote about Privilege was by far the most popular thing I’ve written for this newsletter, which is a testament to my own eloquence, to the fascination of the subject, and to the intensity and insight with which Kahn explored it.

Shamus and I had a great conversation. We talked about the book; his experience as both a student and a teacher at St. Paul’s School; his training at the University of Wisconsin; his good timing in the selection of subjects; what it feels like to be of the elite; and much more.

Leave a comment

Show breakdown (according to AI - I have no idea how closely this tracks the reality, but it feels better than nothing)

00:00 Introduction to the Podcast and Guest

01:07 Discussing the Book 'Privilege'

02:44 Exploring Elite Education and Inequality

04:35 The Role of Quantitative and Qualitative Research

17:21 Personal Background and Experience at St. Paul's

30:21 Changes in Elite Education Over Time

46:55 The Origins of Meritocracy

48:40 Challenges of Meritocracy

49:18 Meritocracy and Social Mobility

51:40 Ethnographic Insights on Privilege

52:57 Understanding Inequality

56:32 The Role of Education in Inequality

57:08 Class and Political Mobilization

01:01:37 American Inequality and Historical Perspectives

01:02:25 The Astor Family and American Finance

01:09:07 The Influence of Wealth in Politics

01:15:54 Navigating Elite Institutions

01:17:44 The Future of Elite Coordination

01:26:22 Concluding Thoughts on Elites and Power

01:29:27 Closing Remarks and Outro


Discussion about this podcast

Eminent Americans
Eminent Americans
Eminent Americans is a newsletter and occasional podcast about the writers and public intellectuals who either are key players in the American intellectual scene or who typify an important aspect of it. So people like Ta-Nehisi Coates, Wesley Yang, Elizabeth Bruenig, Ross Douthat, Nikole Hannah Jones, Jia Tolentino, Freddie Deboer, Rod Dreher, Ibram Kendi, Ezra Klein, Bari Weiss, the Red Scare podcast hosts, Andrew Sullivan, etc.
Although the newsletter will touch on the political and intellectual issues that concern these folks, the focus is less the topics than the people — their backstories, what drives them, how they’ve evolved, who cares the most about them, what role they play in the larger ecosystem, and what trends do they embody or influence.
In one sense, then, it’s a rather meta concept. It’s an intellectual (me) talking about other intellectuals in their roles as intellectuals, and occasionally doing in conversation with yet more intellectuals. From another angle, it’s simply an attempt to investigate and describe the contemporary American scene through and with the people who constitute it.